We know from our e-mail that many visitors are looking for more information about these 'lost' names, but they tend not to fit easily into Tolkien's complete world, and it would be hopelessly confusing to insert them into the main Encyclopedia. So, we've created this 'Excyclopedia', listing some of the most commonly requested subjects from outside the main canon.
As well as those names created by Tolkien himself, we've listed some of those from outside sources, too. So, you'll find that the list also contains a selection of names created for movies and games, or even a few coined by fans. Names in the list that don't come from Tolkien's own writings are marked with an asterisk. It goes without saying that this small compilation is by no means comprehensive. It's simply intended to discuss some of the more commonly mentioned names from outside the main canon of Tolkien's work.
Adûnaphel*
The name of one of the
Ringwraiths, Adûnaphel the Quiet was said to have been one of the three
Nazgûl who were of
Númenórean origin. Indeed the name is
Adûnaic in form, probably meaning something like 'West-daughter - this
Nazgûl is generally presented as female, a notion not supported by Tolkien himself. In fact, Tolkien only named one of the
Nazgûl:
Khamûl. The names of the other eight, including 'Adûnaphel', were created for a role-playing game. For more information, see '
What were the names of the nine Nazgûl?' in the
FAQ.
Ælfwinë
A character of crucial importance during the early phases of Tolkien's stories, Ælfwinë (at first known as
Eriol) was a mariner from England who found the
Straight Road and travelled to
Tol Eressëa, where he was told the history of the
Elder Days. Ælfwinë was the original source, then, for the stories that made up
The Silmarillion. By the time the
The Lord of the Rings came to be written, however, the function of story-collector was taken over by
Bilbo Baggins, and Ælfwinë's dramatic role became redundant. The name 'Ælfwinë' means '
Elf-friend', and it survived in a slightly different form into
The Lord of the Rings as the name of
Éomer's son and heir:
Elfwine.
Alphros
We're given little background about
Prince Imrahil in
The Lord of the Rings, but in the drafts for the Appendices we have much richer detail about his house. This includes his three sons Elphir, Erchirion and Amrothos, and their younger sister
Lothíriel (who became queen to
Éomer).
Imrahil's heir Elphir had a son in turn: Alphros, born in the year
III 3017 - and thus just two years old at the time of the
Battle of the Pelennor - who would become the last
Prince of Dol Amroth named in records.
Ambar
An
Elvish name for the Earth, sometimes also seen in the form
Imbar. It was said to have been used casually as meaning the same thing as
Arda, but properly
Ambar referred only to the habitable part of
Arda. The exact nature of this relationship developed over time: in one late text, for instance, '
Arda' is the Solar System, while 'Ambar' is the planet Earth. The word survives in the
Lord of the Rings, where
Aragorn uses the terms
Ambar-metta at his coronation to mean 'the end of the world'.
Andreth
A wise-woman and prophetess of the
House of Bëor who lived during the later
First Age. Though
mortal, she loved the
Elf Aegnor, and also had a deep friendship with
Aegnor's brother
Finrod. She is best known for her part in the
Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth, the 'Debate of
Finrod and Andreth', in which the two friends discuss profound metaphysical and philosophical matters. Andreth was also known for foretelling the reappearance of
Túrin during the
Last Battle at the end of the world. Despite all these achievements, Andreth makes no appearance in the
Silmarillion proper.
Arafinwë
The name, meaning 'noble
Finwë' given by
Finwë of the
Noldor to his third son. The child was also named Ingalaurë 'golden-haired' by his mother
Indis. He set out for
Middle-earth, following his half-brother
Fëanor, but in the end he abandoned the march and returned to
Valinor. Though he never left
Aman, he is nonetheless best known by the
Sindarin version of his name:
Finarfin.
Argon
The third son of
Fingolfin, who would have been the younger brother of
Fingon and
Turgon. He emerged very late in Tolkien's work, and his story was never developed in any detail; all we know for sure is that he was killed soon after the
Noldor left
Valinor. Tolkien experimented with various possible deaths for Argon, but it seems he was ultimately lost in battle with
Orcs, shortly after the host of
Fingolfin entered
Middle-earth.
Aruman*
In Ralph Bakshi's animated version of
The Lord of the Rings from 1978,
Saruman is sometimes referred to (on an apparently random basis) as 'Aruman'. Nobody has ever produced a completely rational explanation for this - it seems likely that the film-makers thought the similar names '
Saruman' and '
Sauron' might confuse audiences, but that doesn't explain why the
Wizard is also referred to by his true name '
Saruman' within the film.
Belen
Bëor the Old had two sons. The elder of these was was
Baran, and from him the great heroes of the
House of Bëor were descended, including
Barahir and
Beren.
Bëor's younger son left less of a mark on history, to the extent that he is not even named in the published
Silmarillion. He does appear in other accounts, though, where he is named as
Belen. Belen's line was a little less illustrious than his brother's: his most famous descendant was his great-great-granddaughter
Emeldir, who became the wife of
Baran's descendant
Barahir.
Bingo Bolger-Baggins
In the earliest drafts of the work that would become
The Fellowship of the Ring, the
Ring-bearer was not
Frodo, but Bingo Bolger-Baggins (also known simply as Bingo Baggins). He survived in the early forms of the story as far as
Rivendell, and though Tolkien came to dislike the name, he was reluctant to change it. In the end, though, Bingo was renamed
Frodo (actually a name that already emerged as belonging to one of Bingo's companions).
Bingo Baggins himself didn't disappear altogether from
The Lord of the Rings: the name was transferred to one of
Bilbo's uncles, but its status dwindled from the original hero of the story to a single mention in the Appendices.
Boldog
The name of a captain of the
Orcs who fought in the
Wars of Beleriand; he led a raid against
Doriath and was slain on its borders. Boldog is curious in that there are hints that he was not an ordinary
Orc at all, but an evil
spirit in
Orc form. It is even suggested that he was resurrected at least once, and led the
Orcs in other battles during the
First Age.
Brego*
The name
Brego does actually occur in Tolkien's work (it's the name of the second
King of Rohan, taken from the Old English for 'prince' or 'lord'). In Peter Jackson's movie of
The Two Towers, the name is transferred from this ancient prince to a
horse - specifically, the steed of
Théoden's lost son
Théodred, tamed and then released by
Aragorn. Though that episode does not appear in Tolkien's story, there's a nod to the original version when
Aragorn says that
Brego is 'a kingly name'.
Cobas Haven
The small bay on the coasts of
Gondor that lay directly north from
Dol Amroth, into which the River
Ringló flowed at
Edhellond. This name is used in various drafts and preliminary notes for
The Lord of the Rings, though it never appears in the final published version.
Cobas is simply an
Elvish word for a harbour or bay.
Dark Land
A large elongated continent that appears on a single sketch-map of
Arda, associated with the work known as the
Ambarkanta, The Shape of the World, which belongs to an early stage of the development Tolkien's tales. Also labelled 'South Land', the Dark Land lies far to the south of the parts of
Middle-earth known in any detail, and is separated from them by a sea known as the East Sea. It is never referred to again in any text.
Dwar*
A name for one of the
Nazgûl, said to have originated as a conquering warrior-mage who ruled his people as a tyrant, and was seduced by
Sauron through one of the
Nine Rings. Like most of the names of the
Nine Ringwraiths, 'Dwar' does not come from Tolkien himself, but is an invention deriving from a game based on his works. For more information, see '
What were the names of the nine Nazgûl?' in the
FAQ.
Elboron
According to
The Lord of the Rings,
Faramir and
Éowyn had a grandson named
Barahir, so we can be sure they had at least one child. In the drafts for the Appendices, that child is named as 'Elboron', who would have been heir to the
Stewardship of Gondor and
Prince of Ithilien. However, Elboron did not survive into the final version of the text, and it's therefore unclear whether Tolkien meant his name to stand.
Eriol
See Ælfwinë
Er-Mûrazor*
See Mûrazor
Eruman
An earlier form of the name that appears in the published
Silmarillion as '
Araman'. Both forms of the name have the same meaning: 'outside
Aman'.
Figwit*
An
Elf of
Rivendell, played by actor Bret McKenzie in a non-speaking role in the movie
The Fellowship of the Ring. He appears only fleetingly on the screen, but was nevertheless picked out by fans and given the name
Figwit (apparently an acronym from '
Frodo Is Great - Who Is
That?'). On the strength of this fan response, Figwit reappears in the movie version of
The Return of the King (he is the
Elf leading
Arwen's escort on her journey to the
Grey Havens) and in
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey we discover his name:
Lindir.
Fionwë
In
The Lost Tales, the earliest phase of Tolkien's work, the
Valar have children (an idea that was later completely abandoned). Fionwë was one of these - he was no less a character, indeed, than the son of
Manwë and
Varda. In a sense, Fionwë survived into
The Silmarillion. He was the forerunner of
Eönwë, and - transformed into a
Maia - he became
Manwë's herald rather than his son.
Gárulf
A name meaning 'spear-
wolf', belonging to a character mentioned in
The Lord of the Rings but never seen, a
Rider of Rohan slain by
Orcs. In Peter Jackson's movie version of
The Two Towers,
Gárulf does make an appearance, though there he has been transformed into a different species: '
Gárulf' there is the name of the
horse on which two children escape to
Edoras in an early scene of the film.
Gildis
The wife of
Hador Lórindol of
Dor-lómin, and thus grandmother to both
Húrin and
Huor. Gildis is not mentioned in the published
Silmarillion, but she does make an appearance in a genealogical chart reproduced in volume XI of
The History of Middle-earth. Her name appears to mean 'star-woman'.
Gnomes
A word used in much of Tolkien's early work to refer to the people otherwise known as the
Noldor or
Deep Elves. It was originally chosen on etymologicial grounds (the name related to the Greek
gnome, meaning 'thought, intelligence', and so was well suited to this division of the
Elves). However, it was eventually abandoned due to its more common associations with small, earth-dwelling creatures, and never appears in any remotely canonical work.
Grim
An important dweller in the
Westfold of
Rohan, apparently an ancestor of
Grimbold, who fell in the
Battle of the Pelennor. Grim was the founder of
Grimbold's home township of
Grimslade ('Grim's dell'). He is not mentioned in any canonical works, but his existence is revealed in Tolkien's notes on translation with reference to the place name '
Grimslade'.
Gwendelin
One of a long series of names belonging to a character dating back to the inception of Tolkien's tales. The evolution of this name is typical of the complex creative process that Tolkien applied to his characters, especially those dating back to the beginnings of his stories. In the
Lost Tales, she started out as
Tindriel, but was soon renamed
Wendelin, which in turn developed into
Gwendelin. From there, a multitude of different experimental forms appeared: Gwendeling, Gwedheling, Gwedhiling, Gwenniel and Gwenethlin. All of these variations was superseded in turn: in the later versions of the
Silmarillion, this character has evolved into her final form:
Melian the Maia,
Queen of Doriath.
Hadhafang
The sword used by
Arwen in Peter Jackson's movies. The name
Hadhafang means 'Throng-cleaver' (the
Sindarin equivalent of the established
Quenya name
Sangahyando) and the sword itself was said to have belonged at one time to
Idril Celebrindal, the daughter of
Turgon. Though Tolkien does mention
Hadhafang as a sword-name, its history seems to originate entirely from the movies, or their attendant marketing: Tolkien himself never mentions either
Idril or
Arwen possessing a sword of any kind, let alone one famous enough to bear its own name.
Imbar
See Ambar
Indûr Dawndeath*
Another of the invented names for the eight
Nazgûl left unnamed by Tolkien. Indûr was said to have been a nobleman of an eastern nation, who used the
Ring Sauron gave him to gain power in his native lands before he fell fully under the
Dark Lord's domination. For more information, see '
What were the names of the nine Nazgûl?' in the
FAQ.
Ingwiel
Also seen in the earlier forms
Ingil and
Ingwil, this was the name of the son of
Ingwë of the
Vanyar. He is an important character in early stories of the
War of Wrath, in which he led his people across the
Sea to
Middle-earth, where he landed at
Eglarest and beat back the
Orcs that held the shore there.
Kôr
In the earliest phases of Tolkien's tales,
Kôr was the name of a round hill (
kôr being
Elvish for 'round') in the
Pass of Light on which the
Elves built their city of
Túna; the name was preserved by exiled
Elves who later settled on
Tol Eressëa, where they founded a new city named
Kortirion. In later phases of Tolkien's work, these names are thoroughly rearranged: the hill in the
Pass of Light adopted the name
Túna, while the city became known as
Tirion; after this revision, the old name
Kôr fell out of use entirely.
Legolas of Gondolin
The
Legolas of the
Fellowship of the Ring, of course, is a well established character in
The Lord of the Rings, but he was prefigured long before by another Legolas altogether. This earlier character appears in
The Lost Tales, written many years before
The Lord of the Rings, where his sharp eyes help the
Elves of Gondolin escape its destruction, after which he found his way across the
Sea to
Tol Eressëa. After
The Lost Tales, this Legolas disappears from all further retellings of the same story. At this point, the character seems to have been abandoned by Tolkien until his name re-emerged for (apparently) a quite different individual,
Legolas the son of
Thranduil and companion of
Frodo.
Linwë Tinto
See Tinwë Linto.
Lurtz*
A powerful
Orc, probably intended as an
Uruk, introduced in Peter Jackson's movie of
The Fellowship of the Ring. He led
Saruman's Orcs from
Isengard to capture
Hobbits, and was slain in the attempt. No comparable character exists in Tolkien's original book, but the name 'Lurtz' is possibly inspired by
Lugbúrz, the
Orcs' name for
Sauron's Dark Tower.
Makar
In
The Book of Lost Tales, the first incarnation of the stories that would eventually form
The Silmarillion, Makar and his sister Meássë were ferocious warrior
Valar. They delighted in combat, and dwelt in their own halls in
Valinor. In later versions of the stories, both Makar and Meássë disappeared entirely from the pantheon of the
Valar.
Meássë
Originally one of the
Valar, a spear-bearing warrior who dwelt in iron halls in
Valinor with her brother Makar. Makar and Meássë were dark and chaotic
Powers, having more in common with
Melkor than their fellow
Valar, and the warlike brother and sister quickly passed out of Tolkien's legendarium after its first phase.
Morinehtar
According to a very late note, Morinehtar was one of two
Wizards who travelled to
Middle-earth in the
Second Age. Morinehtar's name means 'darkness-slayer', and with his companion Rómestámo he passed into the east of
Middle-earth long before
Gandalf and the other more familiar
Wizards landed there. The story of Morinehtar and Rómestámo does not sit entirely happily with the account of the
Wizards in
The Lord of the Rings, nor with other accounts that name the other two
Wizards as
Alatar and
Pallando. Nonetheless, it is possible that Morinehtar might have found his way into the canonical tradition if Tolkien had had the chance to expand his story. (See the entry for
Ithryn Luin for more detail about Morinehtar's place in canon.)
Pengolodh
One of the greatest loremasters of the
Elves, belonging to the
Lambengolmor, a school of lingusts founded by
Fëanor himself. Pengolodh was born in
Nevrast, but went with his people to dwell in
Gondolin and remained there until its ruin. He was one of the survivors of that cataclysm, preserving what ancient texts he could rescue from the
Fall of the city. He remained in
Middle-earth long after the
War of Wrath at the end of the
First Age, travelling widely, and was even said to have spent time among the
Dwarves of Khazad-dûm. As
Sauron's power began to extend over
Middle-earth, Pengolodh finally took ship into the
West and settled on
Tol Eressëa. It was through this famous loremaster that much of the surviving knowledge of languages and history of the
First Age was said to have been preserved.
Rog
Called the strongest of the
Noldor, Rog was the chief of the house of the Hammer of Wrath in
Gondolin. Many of the members that house were smiths; thus they fought with great maces and their emblems were the anvil and the hammer. According to the earliest version of the
Fall of Gondolin, all this people were lost as the city of
Gondolin fell. In that early version of the tale, Rog was a peer of
Glorfindel and
Ecthelion, but there is no mention of him in the story as it appears in the final
Silmarillion.
Rohald
In the early chapters of
The Hobbit, we have a handful of passing mentions of a white
horse ridden by
Gandalf. In 1960, Tolkien began work on an extensive (and ultimately unpublished) revision of
The Hobbit that expanded the story of
Gandalf's mount enormously. In that new version the
horse gained a name,
Rohald, and something of a history. He was a
horse of
Rivendell who had been lent to
Gandalf by
Elrond, and was returned to his home as
Thorin and Company passed through on their way into the
Misty Mountains.
Rómestámo
A
Wizard, also called
Rómestar and
Rómenstar, though all variations of his name seem to mean 'east-helper'. He was sent, along with Morinehtar, to
Middle-earth in the
Second Age to lend aid to those
Men who rebelled against
Sauron's rule. Rómestámo's story appears only among certain late notes, and is difficult to reconcile with material in
The Lord of the Rings. (See the entry for
Ithryn Luin for more detail about Rómestámo's place in canon.)
Tal-Elmar
The hero of an unfinished story set in the wilds of
Middle-earth during the
Dark Years of the
Second Age. Tal-Elmar was captured as a child, and raised among a clan of warlike
Wild Men who lived in a settlement near the coast. When a fleet of
Númenórean vessels anchored off the shore, the fearful tribe sent Tal-Elmar to investigate, but the
Númenóreans greeted him as a long-lost kinsman. At that point the story breaks off, and no more is told of Tal-Elmar's mysterious origins or his fate.
Tevildo
Named the Prince of
Cats, Tevildo was a huge black cat in the service of
Melkor in the very early
Tale of Tinúviel (in
The Book of Lost Tales 2). In that original version of the story of
Beren and
Lúthien, it was Tevildo who took
Beren prisoner, but was later defeated by
Huan the
Hound of Valinor (a natural nemesis for a Prince of
Cats). In later versions of the tale, Tevildo vanished and his place was taken by
Sauron, but the original combat with
Huan the
hound remained a vital part of the story.
Tinwë Linto
In the Lost Tales, one of various names given to an
Elf-lord who was lost from the
Great Journey, and remained in
Middle-earth. His name was originally
Linwë Tinto, and he was also known as
Tinwelint, and many other variations besides. Originally Lord of the
Elves of
Hísilómë, Tinwë's story changed radically over the years, and eventually he evolved into the character known as
Elu Thingol.
Tindriel
See Gwendelin
Tinwelint
See Tinwë Linto.
Trotter
In the earliest versions of the story that would become
The Fellowship of the Ring, the
Hobbits arrived in
Bree to find, not
Strider, but
Trotter. In those original drafts,
Aragorn of the
Dúnedain had not yet emerged, and instead Trotter is a venturesome
Hobbit who left the
Shire to explore the world. The are several different versions of the Trotter story, including one peculiar variation in which he has a pair of wooden feet. As work progressed on the text, the wandering
Hobbit Trotter was gradually transformed into the
Dúnadan Aragorn.
Uin
An immeasurably vast and ancient whale that dwelt in the depths of the sea. In the earliest versions of Tolkien's legends, it was Uin (at
Ulmo's command) who drew the island of
Tol Eressëa across the
Great Sea, and so brought the
Eldar to
Valinor.
Ulmonan
Ulmo's great sea-halls that lay in the distant west of the world, far beneath the
Outer Ocean. It was from these halls, so deep beneath the sea that even the other
Valar had never seen them, that
Ulmo extended his power into the seas, rivers and streams of the world. The halls of Ulmonan are never mentioned outside the
Lost Tales, but in the published
Silmarillion Ulmo is still said to dwell apart from the other
Valar, and so at least the concept of Ulmonan, if not the halls themselves, survived into the final phase of Tolkien's tales.
Wendelin
See Gwendelin
Zigûr
The
Adûnaic name for
Sauron, literally meaning 'sorceror' and used especially in
Númenor during his time there. The name
Zigûr doesn't appear in the main canon of Tolkien's work, but it is used in Part II of
The Notion Club Papers, a pair of fantastical tales reproduced in volume IX of
The History of Middle-earth.