The fact that Tom appears in Sam's rhyme without any prior introduction might lead to some possible confusion with Tom Bombadil, whom the Hobbits had met just a few chapters before the rhyme appears in the text of The Lord of the Rings. The fact that both these Toms wear distinctive boots might also potentially add to this confusion (as might the fact that a version of Tom's Troll poem appears in the collection titled The Adventures of Tom Bombadil).
To clarify, the two are quite distinct characters, and the details of their stories make this unmistakably clear. Quite apart from the fact that kicking a Troll in the posterior is hardly Tom Bombadil's style, there are some more definitive points to consider. First, the Tom in Sam's rhyme explictly has a father, but Tom Bombadil is described as 'Oldest and Fatherless'. Second, the unfortunate Tom in the rhyme is also said to end up permanently lamed by his misadventures, but Tom Bombadil certainly wasn't lame when he met the Hobbits.
In fact these two characters had quite different literary origins in unrelated poems, and their shared name is no more than coincidence. 'Tom' is simply a common name in Tolkien's universe (it is also used by two members of the Cotton family, and by Tom Pickthorn of the Bree-land, and by one of the Stone-trolls encountered by Bilbo Baggins on his way to Rivendell).
|